City of Vancouver to explore reviving corner stores in neighbourhoods

Jun 25 2020, 8:59 pm

Corner grocery stores played an important role in Vancouver’s residential neighbourhoods decades ago, before the prominence of large chain-owned stores and the municipal government’s practice of discouraging new additional businesses.

Most of the corner stores that remain today are in ageing structures, such as Le Marche St. George in Riley Park-Little Mountain, the Federal Store on Quebec Street in Mount Pleasant, the Wilder Snail on Keefer Street in Strathcona, and West Side Market on West 16th Avenue in Point Grey.

These businesses are in structures built a century ago, with the youngest being the 1940-built Federal Store.

On Wednesday, Vancouver City Council approved a motion submitted by councillor Sarah Kirby-Yung that directs City staff to consider developing policies for allowing new small-scale commercial retail spaces in neighbourhoods over the short-term, and incorporating reimagined corner grocery stores as part of the Vancouver Plan over the longer term.

Under the realities made apparent by the health crisis, she says such businesses in neighbourhoods, within close proximity to residents, are missing from the fabric of the city. A revival of corner stores in the post-pandemic context would provide residents with easy, walkable access to fresh, healthy foods, and other retail and commercial options.

the federal store luncheonette and grocer 2601 quebec street

The Federal Store Luncheonette & Grocer at 2601 Quebec Street, Vancouver. (Google Maps)

“Traditional corner stores played a key role in creating social connection in neighbourhoods, as well as supporting daily needs. Traditional corner stores have been declining in number for decades due to changing consumer patterns and, critically, due to zoning restrictions,” she wrote.

“There is a long history of independent corner grocery stores (including green grocers) hat were minority-owned and played a key role in supporting culturally appropriate food access for Vancouver’s diverse ethnic and cultural communities, and continue to do so today.”

In recent years, the popularity of community farmers’ markets has helped fill the gap left by the lack of corner stores, and they were declared an “essential food source” by the municipal government in April at the peak of the pandemic. During this period, at the height of COVID-19 restrictions, restaurants and cafes in cities around the world — including a handful in Vancouver — also diversified their business by selling groceries and produce, which addressed gaps in small-scale neighbourhood food access.

le marche st george 4393 st george street

Le Marche St. George at 4393 St. George Street, Vancouver. (Google Maps)

“The world that emerges from the COVID-19 pandemic with more people working from home than ever before, will inevitably result in a greater need for neighbourhood amenities and local food infrastructure of coffee shops, restaurants, services, and shopping including the need to access goods right in their own neighbourhood,” wrote Kirby-Yung.

“Local corner stores once filled this role in Vancouver neighbourhoods, providing a place where locals bought fresh milk, cheese, some staples, while also serving as a social gathering place for community.”

According to a 2019 joint study by the City of Vancouver and UBC, these stores emerged from a time when cities were less oriented around motor vehicles, with residents walking to a local corner store for their daily needs.

A number of these stores were constructed near local public schools, with the businesses feeding on the demand for candy and snacks from students. This is still the case today for West Side Market, which is strategically located half a block east from Lord Byng Secondary School.

west side market 3870 W 16th Avenue

West Side Market at 3870 West 16th Avenue, Vancouver. (Google Maps)

But the current affordability issues are a challenge for the survival of the remaining locations, with corner store spaces renovated to become cafes or restaurants in recent years.

“Those shops that survive today are valued for their charm and character and how they contribute to the neighbourhood identity of communities. They provide easy access to useful goods and services and support the creation of walkable, compact communities,” reads the study.

“This evolution highlights the ongoing social value of these stores and their use as gathering spaces. These spaces should continue to be maintained because they foster neighbourhood connections and strengthen community.”

vernon drive grocery 704 vernon drive

Vernon Drive Grocery at 704 Vernon Drive, Vancouver. (Google Maps)

A century ago, those who owned and operated these stores were the city’s new immigrants, including Italian, Chinese, Irish, Japanese, Portuguese, Eastern European, and Scandinavian families. In many instances, these families lived on-site in an upstairs apartment or attached bungalow.

“Local shopkeepers often are deeply connected to their neighbours. They have been known to keep tabs on local families and even offer credit to loyal customers,” adds the study.

“Small-scale retail spaces serve as community anchors because they allow neighbours to meet and form connections.”

But new corner stores began their decline in 1930, when the municipal government, influenced by the Bartholomew Plan of segregating land uses, approved its first comprehensive zoning schedule that prohibited retail from non-commercial districts.

arbutus coffee 2200 arbutus street

Arbutus Coffee at 2200 Arbutus Street, Vancouver. (Google Maps)

cardero cafe 1016 cardero street

Cardero Cafe at 1016 Cardero Street, Vancouver. (Google Maps)

In 1953, a grandfather clause was adopted to protect existing “non-conforming retail,” and in 1983 the Neighbourhood Grocery Store classification was created.

In 2016, the classification was updated to permit the sale of prepared food, as long as the sale of groceries and convenience goods remain the primary purpose of the business.

The existing regulations for these businesses limit store frontage with the street to 50 feet, a maximum floor area of 1,184 sq. ft. for all retail and storage, and up to 16 indoor and outdoor seats.

As of 2019, the analysis found that there are 19 activate isolated retail sites in residential neighbourhoods, 25 active neighbourhood grocery stores, 100 active non-conforming retail sites, 123 deactivated neighbourhood retail sites, and 364 demolished neighbourhood retail sites.

vancouver neighbourhood retail

Vancouver neighbourhood retail locations in the 1930s. (City of Vancouver / UBC)

vancouver neighbourhood retail

Vancouver neighbourhood retail locations in the 2010s. (City of Vancouver / UBC)