Best New York-style pizza restaurants in Edmonton

Jan 11 2023, 11:45 pm

Looking for the best New York-style pizza in Edmonton?

So many places have their own unique version of pizza. Detroit has the crispy edges, Chicago has the deep dish, California has the veggie, the Margherita in Naples, and so on.

The best in the world might just be The Big Apple.

Unless you are lucky enough to travel there all the time, you might find yourself searching for that authentically NY bite of pie. These are typically pizzas with a large hand-tossed thin crust that are often sold in wide slices. The crust is thick and crisp only along its edge, but if it’s done correctly, it’s still soft and thin enough to be folded in half in that classic New York way.

Here are our choices for the best New York-style pizza restaurants in Edmonton.

Tony’s Pizza Palace

This is easily one of the best New York-style pizza restaurants in Calgary.

This Italian spot has been serving YEG for over 60 years, with the fact they are the city’s first-ever NY pizza spot. Made the traditional way, guests can choose their size and toppings for this iconic dish.

Address: 9605 111th Avenue NW, Edmonton

Instagram

Ragazzi

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Ragazzi Bistro (@ragazzibistroyeg)

Boasting authentic, hand-tossed thin-crust pizza, Ragazzi is a go-to if you are in the mood for Italian, New York-style pizza.

Address: 8110 82nd Avenue, Edmonton

Instagram

Sepp’s

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by Sepps Pizza (@seppspizza)

Sepp’s Pizza dishes out massive, mouth-watering New York-style pizza pies. Overflowing with toppings, The Double Pep and The Meat Lover are classics. If you are a simple cheese lover, Sepp’s Classic Cheese is fire.

Address: 11053 86th Avenue NW, Edmonton

Instagram

Community Taps & Pizza

New York- and Detroit-style pizza are both available here, depending on where your tastes lie.

Prefer a thinner-crust pizza topped with mozzarella, grana padano, oregano, and a garlic-oiled crust? Then go with the New York pizza menu.

The classics are all here, but this is a modern pizza joint, after all. The kale pesto, pizza corner donair, and bacon mushroom truffle are just three choices from over 20 different pizzas.

Address: 8232 Gateway Boulevard NW, Edmonton

Instagram

Hogan ShortHogan Short

+ Dished
+ Restaurants & Bars
+ Best of