Podcast about Avril Lavigne “replacement” conspiracy has web sleuths investigating Kate Middleton

Mar 15 2024, 8:01 pm

Remember the Avril Lavigne conspiracy theory that suggests she died and was replaced by a body double? Well, it’s getting the podcast treatment, and listeners are already drawing parallels to the Kate Middleton drama.

At the beginning of March, the BBC released the first episode of its podcast Who Replaced Avril Lavigne? Joanne McNally Investigates.

It’s a bizarre conspiracy theory that has been around for over a decade now.

For those who haven’t gone down that deep, dark rabbit hole, it reportedly stems from a 2011 blog post on a Lavigne fan site based in Brazil. According to the conspiracy, the “Complicated” singer was overwhelmed by the pressures that came with fame as she skyrocketed to stardom in 2003.

That and her grandfather’s death sent her into a deep depression, and the conspiracy theorizes that Lavigne was replaced by a lookalike named Melissa Vandella when the real Avril wanted time off.

The theory goes even further and alleges that Lavigne died by suicide shortly after the release of her debut album, Let Go, in 2002, leaving Vandella to take over as the new Avril Lavigne full-time.

“It’s an internet conspiracy theory which has been eating comedian Joanne McNally ALIVE, and she’s going to do something about it,” reads the BBC’s podcast description.

“In this six-part series, Joanne immerses herself in a mind-bending world of fake celebrity deaths, doppelgangers, conspiracies in an effort to understand how this rumour started and if there’s any truth to it.”

The podcast has two episodes out so far — “What the Hell” and “Here’s to Never Growing Up” — aptly titled with the Canadian pop-punk princess’ bops.

So far, McNally has delved into the Napanee, Ontario, singer’s early career and the world of body doubles in Hollywood outside of movies.

Although the conspiracy has been around since 2011, it has become quite topical again as internet sleuths theorize over the whereabouts of another princess, Kate Middleton.

In January, Kensington Palace revealed that the Princess of Wales was hospitalized for abdominal surgery, but onlookers got more suspicious as days, weeks, and months have gone by without her making any public appearances.

Two months, a grainy paparazzi photo, an apparently photoshopped Mother’s Day photo, and a Princess apology later, conspiracy theories are running wild.

Many are comparing the royal drama to Lavigne’s urban legend.

Lavigne actually hilariously addressed her long-running conspiracy in a TikTok last year where she punched and kicked comments she frequently gets on Instagram.

What do you think about these theories? Let us know in the comments.

Isabelle DoctoIsabelle Docto

+ Curated
+ Pop Culture
+ Media
+ Celebrities
+ Canada