The Toronto Maple Leafs’ season might still be alive if Friday night’s controversial “no goal” call had gone in their favour.

Down 2-1 in the second period, Morgan Rielly appeared to tie the game up. The Leafs defenceman took the puck to the net, and then it disappeared under the pad of Florida Panthers goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky.

After a lengthy video replay, it was determined that the puck didn’t cross the goal line before the referee’s whistle had blown.

The thing is, the instant replay footage appears to show otherwise.

NO GOAL! ❌

Morgan Rielly jams the puck on the net, but it is called no goal and confirmed after a video review by the Situation Room in Toronto. pic.twitter.com/zgoSte9fU7

— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) May 13, 2023

Images from certain angles actually show the puck fully crossing the line.

This is the best look yet. #Leafs might have reason to be upset. pic.twitter.com/PX50HizNnz

— Rob Williams (@RobTheHockeyGuy) May 13, 2023

Um … pic.twitter.com/xydsYfpbny

— Chip Alexander (@ice_chip) May 13, 2023

While Toronto general manager Kyle Dubas was visibly infuriated with the call, fans at Scotiabank Arena chanted “bullsh*t” and littered the ice with debris.

After the game ended in an overtime loss and elimination for the postseason, the Leafs players also seemed baffled by the officials’ decision on the play.

“I thought it was in,” Leafs captain John Tavares said after the game. “I was heading to the net. I was right there.”

Tavares concluded that “obviously, they [the officials] looked at it and had their reasoning.”

Meanwhile, Sheldon Keefe said he was told there was no clear view of the puck crossing the line before the play was blown dead.

“The explanation I got was that there wasn’t a clear and conclusive view of the initial shot showing it was in. There was that,” he said. “The other shot of the puck in the net, they said, was after the play and the play was dead. That’s it.”

The NHL later released a statement saying the “referee deemed the play dead prior to the puck crossing the Florida line.”

Official Review Explanation pic.twitter.com/ZZTp7cJnio

— Elliotte Friedman (@FriedgeHNIC) May 13, 2023

As for Rielly, the player who would have been credited with the big goal, he offered a minimal explanation to reporters.

“It happened quickly, and obviously they reviewed it. So, it is what it is.”

You might also like:
• Was it in? Fans litter ice after video replay decision goes against Leafs
• "I love these guys": Rielly doesn't want Leafs' core broken up

With files from Daily Hive’s Rob Williams