Editor’s note: The names in this story have been removed for privacy reasons.
A BC renter was the subject of a legal dispute regarding unpaid rent, and they made some serious allegations about why they didn’t pay.
D.A told the BC Civil Resolution Tribunal that K.B, the renter, failed to pay rent in June 2023.
She asked the tribunal to order K.B. to pay $740.24 in unpaid rent and utilities.
In response and defence, the renter denied owing anything. She added that she was forced to move out because the living situation was “hostile.”
K.B. also filed a counterclaim, which included $186.66 for being overcharged for rent, $500 for false representation, and $523.34 for the rent she had to pay at a new residence. She also asked the tribunal for compensation of $500 for “her mental and emotional harm” and $46.76 for lost wages due to “false imprisonment” by another person named in the case, N.C., who was one of the roommates.
- You might also like:
- BC roommates face off in legal fight over vacated room's rent
- BC roommates claim thousands in fight over "unbearable" living conditions
- BC tenant claims two months’ rent in court after roommate abruptly leaves
According to the tribunal decision available online, in late 2022, D.A. was going to leave the province, so she decided to sublet her room.. K.B. asked for a written contract, which didn’t include the monthly rent rate but stated it would be the same as the master lease: $700 per month plus utilities. The agreement lasted between October 1, 2022, and June 30, 2023.
K.B. moved out on May 31, 2023, without providing notice. She claimed she moved out because of her roommates’ “abusive, harassing, and intimidating conduct.”
The tribunal had evidence that in March, April and May 2023, the roommates were often in conflict, sometimes to a degree that involved the police.
K.B. argued that this invalidated the rental contract, but the tribunal said renting the room “was not conditional upon being compatible with her roommates.”
K.B. texted Agbaje that she was moving on May 31, 2023, and D.A. responded “okay.”
She followed up by saying that K.B. had to pay June’s rent. The tribunal agreed and ordered K.B. to pay $740.24 for unpaid rent and utilities.
When it comes to K.B’s claims of false imprisonment, she did provide evidence, which included video.
K.B. said that one day in May 2023, when she was trying to go to work, she was “held hostage” by D.A.. She also claims that D.A. was sitting in a chair blocking an exit door. Other evidence she provided included a text to her workplace saying she would be 30 minutes late. In another text, she reported being held hostage to Agbaje, who had “already heard about it from [N.C].”
The renter she could not prove damages for her numerous claims, and the tribunal dismissed them.
K.B. was ordered to pay D.A. $911.10 due to the BC tribunal dispute, including unpaid rent, utilities, and tribunal fees.