There’s no shame in bringing a bought dessert to Thanksgiving dinner.
Especially if your pumpkin pie hails from one of Toronto’s top bake shops. Pre-orders are highly recommended and should be made ASAP to ensure you’re not pie-less on the big day.
Here’s where to find the best pumpkin pies in Toronto.
This pastry shop boasts two Toronto locations that are beloved for their baked goods. In season right now, find popular picks including pumpkin pies, apple crumbles, and gluten-free chocolate tortes.
Address: 1121 Queen Street East, Toronto
Address: 3347 Yonge Street, Toronto
The Italian bakery in the east end is home to traditional pies piped with stiff whipped cream and dusted with cinnamon. Stave off the urge to eat it all in the car before you get home with a pumpkin white mocha from the espresso bar.
Address: 6758 Kingston Road, Toronto
Go traditional or opt for a pumpkin pie encircled with pepitas and spiced sugar from this Eglinton West bakeshop. Aside from pie, find festive desserts ranging from spiced pumpkin cheesecake and pumpkin bundt cakes, plus all sorts of apple desserts.
Address: 420 Eglinton Avenue West, Toronto
Pumpkin pies featuring buttery, flakey crusts are among the many festive fall desserts on offer at this Etobicoke institution. Pumpkin tarts, pumpkin cheesecake doughnuts, and apple crumbles are just a few of the alternatives.
Address: 374 Royal York Road, Etobicoke
Get your orders in ASAP at this Avenue Road bakeshop offering chocolate pumpkin pie, caramel apple cheesecakes and Jacked-Up pumpkin pies layered with salted caramel, whipped cream, and candied pecans.
Address: 1970 Avenue Road, Toronto
Pre-order pumpkin pies from this bake shop situated across from Trinity Bellwoods. Pick up is available Friday to Sunday in store on Thanksgiving weekend or get yours delivered by ordering online!
Address: 1006 Dundas Street West, Toronto
The pie specialist in Kensington Market will be a flurry of activity on Thanksgiving weekend. Here you’ll find every type of pie imaginable including seasonal favourites; pumpkin pie, pear cranberry pie, minced meat(less).
Address: 287 Augusta Avenue, Toronto
Buttery pastry and rich pumpkin filling finished with decorative leaves is the perfect sweet note to end on at any fall feast. Whipped cream not included.
Address: 173 Danforth Avenue, Toronto
Bunner’s Bake Shop
100% vegan, gluten-free, and soy-free these 9″ will satisfy classic cravings by employing the ultimat “autumn trifecta: cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg!”
Address: 3054 Dundas Street West, Toronto Kensington: 647-350-2975
Address: 244 Augusta Avenue, Toronto
The perfect finish to a turkey dinner are these individual-sized pumpkin (and pecan) tarts. These petite treats are perfect for singles, duos and divisive households that can’t commit to a whole pie. Family-size pies available too.
Address: 780 Queen Street West, Toronto
Address: 1099 Yonge Street, Toronto
Address: The PATH, Richmond Adelaide Centre, Toronto
Address: Yorkdale Mall, 3401 Dufferin Street, Toronto
- Where to eat a Thanksgiving sandwich any time of year in Toronto
- 15 restaurants serving Thanksgiving dinner in Toronto this year
- Where to get Thanksgiving Dinner to-go in Toronto 2017