Outrage over steep touring tax for international musicians playing in Canada

The federal government has put up a major barrier for international musicians and artists through changes to the federally mandated Temporary Foreign Workers program. The new fees to bring in international artists have exponentially increased and will likely make it too expensive for many up and coming international acts and their touring staff to play in Canada.
The fees were quietly hiked by Stephen Harper’s Conservative government on July 31, which will require each small entertainment and live music venue to pay a non-refundable $275 application fee for each “foreign” musician, crew member and entourage touring with the band (tour manager, guitar tech, sound person, wardrobe, etc.). In addition to the new $275 fee, an additional $150 work permit fee must also be paid for these musicians and crew members.
Altogether, these new fees mean each small venue must now pay $425 in federal fees per international artist and crew member. If their application is rejected, their money will not be returned and they will be required to pay the fees again should they choose to reapply.
Under the previous system, the fee was just $150 for each band member to a maximum of $450 for the entire band. It was also a one-time fee for entering and working in Canada, where they could play at any venue. These one-time fees under the old system could also be split between the venues where the artists are playing.
The steep new fees particularly hurt small live entertainment venues like restaurants, bars and clubs, where bringing in a six-person band with a four-member crew could cost each small venue an excess of $4,000 in federally mandated fees per show. This is in addition to the performance fees that musicians and artists regularly charge for their time. These are not costs that most small businesses can afford.
Simply put, this means it will be cost prohibitive for small live entertainment venues to bring in such international acts, particularly indie and jazz musicians from the United States. Small venue owners and their event planners and promoters can increase cover charges and ticket prices exponentially to account for the steep new “touring tax”, but it is unlikely patrons will be willing to pay for such high costs given that profits margins as is are already thin.
Small live entertainment venues could see a significant decline in attendance numbers and revenue if they are continuously forced to turn away talented international performers merely because of the prohibitive costs.
Against mounting criticism and public opposition, federal employment, social development and multiculturalism minister Jason Kenney has defended the new fees, arguing it saves the federal government money. He claims the changes shift the cost of administering the applications from the taxpayer to the employer and ticket holder.
Kenney also argues that it will give Canadian artists and bands better more opportunities to perform at venues. As well, an exception exists for touring international musicians that are performing several tour dates (such as Jay Z and Justin Timberlake’s “Legends of Summer” at BC Place Stadium) or musicians performing at festivals (such as Squamish Festival).
Up and coming Canadian artists often appreciate the opportunities to perform with international artists as a means of giving them more exposure. As well, international musicians often boost the Canadian economy with the many additional events they create at venues. Their presence also provides inspiration for Canadian youth to pursue music and creates more opportunities for local arts and the sharing of culture and ideas.
However, in a matter of months, the impact of the fees will be telling and could soon prove to create the opposite intended effect when musicians stop crossing into Canada to perform restaurants, bars and clubs.
Forget “No-Fun-City.” Can you say “No-Fun-Country”?
Sign the petition to repeal the $425 touring tax
To date, nearly 110,000 people have signed the petition for the federal government to repeal the $425 fee per international artist and crew member at each venue performed.
Click here to sign the petition.
Be sure to also share this article and petition with your friends and to also contact your local Member of Parliament.
The petition reads:
…Today we take a stand for the development of culture and performance arts. The implications of allowing such additional fees will hinder the potential for talented international artists whom simply aim to perform for their fans and expand their recognition. This new regulation will impact fans of all music from electronic to punk to jazz.
Canada’s introduction of such a fee should not be taken lightly, nor excused. The development of our culture on a global scale and the opportunity to invite talents from beyond our borders is something to be cherished and appreciated, not taxed in such a way that will only discourage Canadian talent buyers from welcoming international talent.
With this inflation of upfront fees associated to bringing an international artist to Canada, the government is taking a clear stance of desired control over a culture that blossoms with freedom and deserve support rather than increased financial responsibility.
Sign your name to this petition and share it with those whom you feel will also stand behind challenging such a greedy and unmerited demand that will strangle local small businesses and those attempting to welcome international talent to Canada, growing our cultural diversity and global notoriety.
Twitter Reaction
@kenneyjason, an American musician cancelled their show tonight in Van b/c of your new fees. What about tax revenue those shows bring in?
— Tim Philpott (@tim_philpott) September 2, 2013
@kenneyjason How many concert promoters are going to lose their jobs thanks to the new fees against touring foreign musicians? #cdnpoli
— J R (@SBXIII) September 2, 2013
@kenneyjason your LMO fees imposed on international touring musicians shows a complete lack of understanding of the economics of music.
— Dental Damnation (@DentalDamnation) September 2, 2013
@kenneyjason Please do NOT limit foreign musicians by exorbitant “head taxes.” http://t.co/T4U6R9vK7F
— kerry brennan (@HalifaxKerry) September 2, 2013
@kenneyjason Presenting live music in Canada, in the private sector is already very difficult and margins are slim..
— Robert Jensen (@RobertJensen2) September 2, 2013
@kenneyjason The venues that hire hundreds of Canadian musicians each year rely heavily on the revenue from intl artist to stay afloat.
— Robert Jensen (@RobertJensen2) September 2, 2013
@kenneyjason The lion’s share of intl artist fees are spent in Canada on hotels, meals, flights, car rentals, publicity, etc.
— Robert Jensen (@RobertJensen2) September 2, 2013
@kenneyjason If an international act has a $50,000.00 Canadian tour, chances are at least $40,000.00 of that will remain in Canada.
— Robert Jensen (@RobertJensen2) September 2, 2013
.@kenneyjason Show me 5 artists who complained about foreign artists getting booked and I’ll show you 500 in Ottawa that are fine with it
— Lefty McRighty (@leftydammit) September 1, 2013
@kenneyjason the levies against small music venues is insanity. Canadians deserve to experience culture from abroad here. #music4Canada
— Chronograph Records (@chronorecords) September 1, 2013
@kenneyjason musicians/venues don’t make much money, reverse that fee now!
— Heather Stock (@heathercanada) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason Just found out about the international musician tariff. This is not about government funds, but misplaced protectionism. Stop!
— Ron Porteous (@portera) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason you clearly don’t understand the financial reality of touring musicians
— Keith Jolie (@keithjolie) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason why do we allow other companies to hire on the cheap temp foreign workers? Musicians have unique skill sets
— stone ax (@chairitable) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason Do you even like music? Or do you just hate indie bands and love justin bieber? #changeapplicationfee #jasonkennyhatesgoodmusic
— John (@johnsiriopoulos) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason @CandiceBergenMP These fee increases will make it next to impossible for new American bands to visit Canada. Thanks assholes
— Elliot L (@ElFanglord) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason All the progress Canada has made on the International music scene is being BADLY damaged by your uneducated policy
— Mike Jones (@nuttyskadork) August 31, 2013
What is with this new music charge by Feds? Hearing shows are already canceling? @kenneyjason @Blues_Can #livemusic #yycmusic #cdnpoli
— Robert Dickinson (@robdickinsonAB) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason do you even know how the music scene works? My band gets on plenty of foreign bands bills who could not afford this.
— Zach (@ZacharyPaterson) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason Charging visiting artists a punitive fee when they play in Canada is crass cultural protectionism, please put a stop to this!
— Terry Bursey (@tkbursey) August 31, 2013
@JamesTPorter @ElectDanielle @kenneyjason Stop hammering the small businessman. Live music venues are crucial to Calgary. #yyc yycvote
— Kevin Taylor (@Taylor4Ward7) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason @leftydammit Being a musician is not like being a lawyer. There is no first crack for Cdns when it comes to music. Wake up JK.
— d petrella (@petrellad) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason I pay taxes. Canadian bookers and promoters pay taxes. The Canadian independent music industry pays taxes. We call bullshit.
— Saragh Adams (@SaraghAdams) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason this is the most uninformed idea is history. It will cripple the music scene. Good luck getting elected again if this passes.
— Jeff Sanna (@JeffSanna) August 31, 2013
@kenneyjason Why do bars/restaurants require LMO’s for out of country musicians, but concerts/festivals do not? What’s the difference?
— Tony Montana (@Katnip403) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason @snuttall94 Are we not trying to create jobs and help businesses to grow? All this is gonna do is hurt small business/music.
— Spencer Kyle (@Spenny_kyle) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason I am going to assume you did not even consider Buskers. Lets tax people as an incentive to not come back to Canada, smart…
— Bobart (@Bobart000) August 30, 2013
To @kenneyjason : Please stop trying to kill the independent music industry. You’re not doing Canada any favours here right now.
— A Sky Gazer (@askygazer) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason Mr Kenney this new bill regarding new international band fees will effectively squash many music scenes in cities across Canada
— Nolan Grad (@mintyfreshnolan) August 30, 2013
The Canadian government is screwing over small venues and artists but big venues get a pass? @kenneyjason http://t.co/ZtyaJJzs21
— Blackout BBQ (@BlackoutBBQ) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason it reflects a lack of understanding of the Canadian music scene. I’d be happy to explain a typical tour budget as a foreigner.
— Remy Le Boeuf (@RemyLeBoeuf) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason Your new LMA fee for foreign musicians hurts jazz musicians/venues in particular–they are small venues with low budgets.
— Remy Le Boeuf (@RemyLeBoeuf) August 30, 2013
@ReimannPeter @kenneyjason @chairitable totally agree the music scene is a vital component to other industries, arts/culture and tourism
— Nati Herron (@natiherron) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason each foreign band we can no longer afford to book will cost staff ~$1200 in lost wages and tips annually $15000 out of pocket
— Broken City Calgary (@TheBrokenCity) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason Don’t ruin live music! Do not impose Foreign fees for musicians in small venues. They don’t cost tax payers anything!
— Mike Angus (@chazimitaz) August 30, 2013
@DJDynamicNC @kenneyjason The explanation is that they forgot to consult with the music industry on what would most help the music industry.
— Andrew Jones (@CheckeredOwl) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason That project of an added fee for international musicians is simply ridiculous. This would hurt both #economy AND #culture.
— David Pontbriand (@DavidPontbriand) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason were really not getting paid, as an artist I don’t care if I get paid for shows as long as I’m getting share my music w/ others
— Storm Calysta (@StormCalysta) August 30, 2013
@kenneyjason to charge artists, especially unsigned artists, that whopping fee is ludacris. We can’t afford it, & all we want is to perform.
— Storm Calysta (@StormCalysta) August 30, 2013
International bands aren’t foreign workers depriving Canadians of work @kenneyjason, you and the #CPC are just hurting small Canadian venues
— Carmen (@candyxjackie) August 30, 2013
Featured image: Iwona Kellie