
In a week where the Toronto Blue Jays were expecting to be celebrating a playoff berth, they’re currently finding themselves still tinkering with key roster spots.
And questions are swirling about, again, one of the team’s key pieces — and if closer Jordan Romano is ready to be relied upon come playoff time.
Romano was named the team’s closer in the 2021 season and has made the All-Star game in each of the last two seasons. Since his first year as the full-time closer, Romano has picked up 95 saves, fourth in the MLB over that span.
But baseball is a “what-have-you-done-for-me-lately?” style sport, and Romano’s recent performances haven’t exactly been inspiring.
Over his last 10 appearances since September 4, Romano has a 5.40 ERA and 10 hits to go along with six earned runs across 10 innings pitched. It’s a small sample size over the course of a long season, but it’s also exactly the worst time of the year to not be exactly looking like yourself.
On Tuesday night, Romano was rocked in the ninth inning of a 0-0 game by an Austin Wells home run that gave the New York Yankees a 2-0 lead they wouldn’t relinquish in the bottom half. His appearance on Saturday didn’t go much better, giving up the loss in walk-off fashion in a 7-6 defeat to the Tampa Bay Rays after coming in with a 6-5 lead.
Romano’s been increasingly volatile in non-save situations this year, allowing five home runs to just one in save situations while also seeing his ERA balloon from 2.38 to 4.32, as per Sportsnet Stats.
Jordan Romano has faced some challenges in non-save situations this season pic.twitter.com/0VRPXi6JYc
— Sportsnet Stats (@SNstats) September 27, 2023
Currently dealing with a fingernail issue, Romano might not exactly have his best stuff right now, although manager John Schneider is still publicly backing his pitcher.
“The life of a closer is tough and you have to have a very short-term memory,” Schneider told reporters Tuesday night. “You look at the result, it wasn’t ideal tonight or Saturday, but you look at the overall body of work and you look at the stuff and the stuff was there.”
But even if his manager has his back, Blue Jays fans aren’t exactly confident in Romano right now:
Blue Jays are screwed come playoff time if Romano is closing out a close game. https://t.co/yBH5LUmkSS
— David (@David_Bernardi7) September 27, 2023
I don’t care what the stats say – Jordan Romano is not a major league closer
— Ryan Popowich (@DownWithPopo) September 27, 2023
Jordan Romano is going to single-handedly keep the Jays out of the playoffs.#bluejays #nextlevel pic.twitter.com/uHI0tvuMgg
— Drew P. Weiner (@DrewWeinerPR) September 27, 2023
I see Jordan Romano was Jordan Romano last night. Don't @ me. In a must win playoff game, my confidence in going to him in a high pressure spot is not high right now. #NextLevel
— Allan Etmanski (@allanetmanski) September 27, 2023
Jordan Romano is highly overrated and shouldn’t be relied upon in the playoffs.
— Connor McKatz 🛢️🛢️🛢️ (@ConnorMcKatz) September 27, 2023
If you're not worried about Romano you're not paying attention. Hasn't looked near himself for quite a while.
Stay ready, Jordan Hicks. https://t.co/dFjzv5dNRg
— They call me Mister Bort 🦥 (@jon_barratt) September 27, 2023
Jordan Romano has to be replaced as closer, stuff simply is not good!!
— tim sheppard (@toolman068) September 27, 2023
I want to like Jordan Romano but his performances of late have made it hard to find positives in him.
— Ryan Pollock (@ryanpollock11) September 27, 2023
Sure, Toronto still has five games left to close out their season — and the possibility of finding themselves in the postseason as soon as tomorrow, should the right results go their way. But should they have any hope of a long postseason run, they’ll likely need Romano to find his form soon, or find someone else who can perform in high-leverage spots.
- You might also like:
- Here's how the Blue Jays can clinch a playoff spot this week